Senator BIRMINGHAM (South Australia—Minister for Trade, Tourism and Investment and Deputy Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:44): What an outrageous smear from Senator Pratt! Senator Pratt ought to stand up and apologise to this Senate for misleading this Senate. The fact that the families whose children attend childcare centres operated by Mr Dutton's wife are in some way receiving fee relief like any other Australian family should not be used in that type of personal smear from Senator Pratt, and she should be ashamed of herself.
In this debate Shorten, Bill, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Ramsey, Rowan, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Zimmerman, Trent, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Plibersek, Tanya, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Bandt, Adam, MP Morrison, Scott, MP O'Dowd, Ken, MP McCormack, Michael, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Wicks, Lucy, MP Dutton, Peter, MP King, Catherine, MP Hunt, Greg, MP Morton, Ben, MP Taylor, Angus, MP Butler, Mark, MP Wallace, Andrew, MP O'Dwyer, Kelly, MP Husic, Ed, MP Keenan, Michael, MP Hartsuyker, Luke, MP Hunt, Greg, MP Neumann, Shayne, MP Dutton, Peter, MP Crewther, Chris, MP Tudge, Alan, MP Dreyfus, Mark, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Porter, Christian, MP Sudmalis, Ann, MP Tehan, Dan, MP Gallacher, Sen Alex Cormann, Sen Mathias Gallacher, Sen Alex Cormann, Sen Mathias Gallacher, Sen Alex Cormann, Sen Mathias Paterson, Sen James Cormann, Sen Mathias Paterson, Sen James Cormann, Sen Mathias Paterson, Sen James Cormann, Sen Mathias Sterle, Sen Glenn Cormann, Sen Mathias Sterle, Sen Glenn Cormann, Sen Mathias Sterle, Sen Glenn Cormann, Sen Mathias Molan, Sen Jim Birmingham, Sen Simon Molan, Sen Jim Birmingham, Sen Simon Molan, Sen Jim Birmingham, Sen Simon Di Natale, Sen Richard Cormann, Sen Mathias Di Natale, Sen Richard Cormann, Sen Mathias Di Natale, Sen Richard Cormann, Sen Mathias Kitching, Sen Kimberley Cormann, Sen Mathias Kitching, Sen Kimberley Cormann, Sen Mathias Kitching, Sen Kimberley Cormann, Sen Mathias Hanson, Sen Pauline Birmingham, Sen Simon Hanson, Sen Pauline Birmingham, Sen Simon Hanson, Sen Pauline Birmingham, Sen Simon Brockman, Sen Slade Birmingham, Sen Simon Brockman, Sen Slade Birmingham, Sen Simon Brockman, Sen Slade Birmingham, Sen Simon Pratt, Sen Louise Birmingham, Sen Simon Pratt, Sen Louise Birmingham, Sen Simon Pratt, Sen Louise Macdonald, Sen Ian Canavan, Sen Matthew Macdonald, Sen Ian Canavan, Sen Matthew Macdonald, Sen Ian Canavan, Sen Matthew Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Cormann, Sen Mathias Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Cormann, Sen Mathias Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Cormann, Sen Mathias Marshall, Sen Gavin Cormann, Sen Mathias Marshall, Sen Gavin Cormann, Sen Mathias Marshall, Sen Gavin Cormann, Sen Mathias Williams, Sen John McKenzie, Sen Bridget Williams, Sen John McKenzie, Sen Bridget Williams, Sen John McKenzie, Sen Bridget