Senator BRANDIS (Queensland—Attorney-General, Vice-President of the Executive Council and Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:15): We always hear the echoes of the old class war from you, Senator Doug Cameron, don't we, in that inimitable accent of yours from the shipyards of Glasgow. Senator Cameron, the facts are against you. The person who, more than anyone else, has traded away the rights, benefits, pay and conditions of workers is Mr Bill Shorten, as the Heydon royal commission found out in the case of the workers of Chiquita Mushrooms, in the case of the workers at Clean Event and, as we have seen more recently, in the case of workers in the food industry, where even— The PRESIDENT: A point of order, Senator Cameron? Senator Cameron: The question went to the issue of a $50 billion tax cut whilst cutting the wages of the lowest-paid workers in this country. The minister again has not addressed that. He should be drawn to the question. The PRESIDENT: Thank you, Senator Cameron. The question commenced with 'Why is the government supporting' and the Attorney-General has been answering the question. Senator BRANDIS: Lest it was lost on Senator Cameron, we respect the decisions of the Fair Work Commission as an independent arbiter. If anyone has sold low-paid workers down the river, just look at your own leader, Senator. Look at what he did to the workers of Chiquita Mushrooms. Look at what he did to the workers at Clean Event. Look at what he did to so many other Australian workers whose terms and conditions he sold down the river for his dirty deals. (Time expired)