Senator KIM CARR (Victoria) (14:52): I note that the minister has not been able to explain why it is they are taking $500 million— The PRESIDENT: No. You need to come to a question. Senator KIM CARR: Does the minister support Mr Macfarlane's efforts to keep the industry in Australia or does he support the indifference radiated by the Prime Minister and the banker's friend, Mr Hockey? What action are you taking, Minister, representing the people of Victoria to secure the 30,000 jobs in that state?