Mr DUTTON (Dickson) (14:59): My question is to the Prime Minister. I refer to the Prime Minister's following statements, made when she was shadow minister for health: 'Labor is committed to the maintenance of the private health insurance rebate, and I have given an ironclad guarantee of that on a number of occasions.' Honourable members interjecting— The SPEAKER: Order! The member for Dickson will repeat the question and he will be heard in complete silence. Mr DUTTON: I will just wait for the clock to restart, Mr Speaker, if I may. The SPEAKER: The clock will restart. When the House is completely silent the member will have the opportunity to ask his question so that the Prime Minister is able to hear what he is asking, and so that she is able to be directly relevant. Mr DUTTON: I refer to the Prime Minister's following statements, made when she was shadow minister for health, 'Labor is committed to the maintenance of the private health insurance rebate, and I have given an ironclad guarantee of that on a number of occasions.' Further: 'I grow tired of saying this. Labor is committed to the 30 per cent private health insurance rebate.' When can the Australian people expect the Prime Minister to stand by any of her ironclad commitments?