Mr KATTER (Kennedy) (14:15): Environment minister, the latest Spectator cover page 'Chalumbin, the new Franklin' details Queensland's in principle approval of 86 wind turbines, each 308 feet high. Minister, won't it destroy 3,000 acres of periphery jungle, kill birdlife, cost taxpayers a fortune and generate minuscule electricity, and its working life is only 19 years? Whilst applauding your break on Chalumbin, wouldn't you agree with environment professor Nevard that Chalumbin transforms 200 kilometres of nature wonderland into an industrial wasteland?
In this debate Dutton, Peter Craig MP Albanese, Anthony MP Phillips, Fiona MP Collins, Julie Maree MP Ley, Sussan Penelope MP Burney, Linda Jean MP Georganas, Steve MP Rishworth, Amanda Louise MP Plibersek, Tanya Joan MP Miller-Frost, Louise MP Burke, Tony MP Taylor, Angus MP Chalmers, Jim MP Repacholi, Dan MP Chalmers, Jim MP Gillespie, David MP Plibersek, Tanya Joan MP Thwaites, Kate MP Hill, Julian MP Mitchell, Rob MP Shorten, Bill MP Gee, Andrew MP Jones, Stephen MP Lim, Sam MP Butler, Mark Christopher MP Fletcher, Paul MP Shorten, Bill MP Fernando, Cassandra MP Albanese, Anthony MP O'Sullivan, Sen Matt Gallagher, Sen Katy O'Sullivan, Sen Matt Gallagher, Sen Katy O'Sullivan, Sen Matt Gallagher, Sen Katy Payman, Sen Fatima Farrell, Sen Don Payman, Sen Fatima Farrell, Sen Don Payman, Sen Fatima Farrell, Sen Don Birmingham, Sen Simon Farrell, Sen Don Birmingham, Sen Simon Farrell, Sen Don Birmingham, Sen Simon Farrell, Sen Don Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah Wong, Sen Penny Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah Wong, Sen Penny Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah Wong, Sen Penny Grogan, Sen Karen Gallagher, Sen Katy Grogan, Sen Karen Gallagher, Sen Katy Grogan, Sen Karen Gallagher, Sen Katy Tyrrell, Sen Tammy Gallagher, Sen Katy Tyrrell, Sen Tammy Gallagher, Sen Katy Tyrrell, Sen Tammy Gallagher, Sen Katy Duniam, Sen Jonathon Wong, Sen Penny Duniam, Sen Jonathon Wong, Sen Penny Duniam, Sen Jonathon Wong, Sen Penny Babet, Sen Ralph Gallagher, Sen Katy Babet, Sen Ralph Gallagher, Sen Katy Babet, Sen Ralph Gallagher, Sen Katy Sheldon, Sen Tony Watt, Sen Murray Sheldon, Sen Tony Watt, Sen Murray Sheldon, Sen Tony Watt, Sen Murray Nampijinpa Price, Sen Jacinta Gallagher, Sen Katy Nampijinpa Price, Sen Jacinta Gallagher, Sen Katy Nampijinpa Price, Sen Jacinta Gallagher, Sen Katy Ciccone, Sen Raff Wong, Sen Penny Ciccone, Sen Raff Wong, Sen Penny Ciccone, Sen Raff Wong, Sen Penny