Mr HOWARTH (Petrie) (14:50): My question is to the Prime Minister. Kazik is 81 years old and lives with his 78-year-old wife, Tatiana, in Griffin within my electorate of Petrie. Kazik and Tatiana's latest gas bill is 72 per cent higher than their previous bill. This increase means they'll have to make difficult decisions this winter about whether to eat or whether to stay warm. Why do Australian families always pay more under Labor? Mr Brian Mitchell interjecting— The SPEAKER: The member for Lyons is warned.