Mr BOWEN (McMahon—Minister for Climate Change and Energy) (14:48): I thank the honourable member for the question about modelling. Yes, the modelling commissioned by the Labor Party when in opposition is very important, because it underlines the fact that renewable energy is the cheapest form of energy. It underlines the fact that renewable energy will create jobs across our country. Now, we understand that. Any sensible economist understands that. Those opposite are still struggling with that. They're still struggling with it. They think that the cheapest form of energy is nuclear. Mr Ted O'Brien interjecting— The SPEAKER: Member for Fairfax! The member for Fairfax has asked his question. Mr BOWEN: The Leader of the Opposition was asked the other week about nuclear energy being more expensive and he said, 'No, no, no. That's an assertion by Chris Bowen. It's not supported by the facts from Europe or North America.' Mr Ted O'Brien interjecting— The SPEAKER: The member for Fairfax is warned. Mr BOWEN : Now, the Leader of the Opposition is onto me. He's onto me. I did call the CSIRO and the Australian Energy Market Operator regarding the GenCost report and asked them to write that nuclear energy is the most expensive form of energy. And then I got onto Stanford University and I asked them. Then I got onto Harvard University and I asked them. Then I got onto the International Energy Agency and I asked them. Then I got onto the international nuclear report and I asked them. These are all groups who say that nuclear energy is the most expensive form of energy, but it has passed by the Leader of the Opposition. Mr Rick Wilson interjecting— The SPEAKER: Member for O'Connor, I'm trying to hear from the Manager of Opposition Business. Mr Fletcher: Mr Speaker, my point of order is on relevance. You have previously asked a minister to return to a question because he's 'had a preamble'. The minister has had a preamble. He needs to answer the question: why has the modelling been taken down from the website? The SPEAKER: The question contained more than that one component. I'm listening carefully to the minister, and I ask him to return to the question specifically regarding the modelling. Mr BOWEN: We're happy to talk about modelling. Mr Ted O'Brien interjecting— The SPEAKER: The member for Fairfax! Mr BOWEN: I look forward to the opposition releasing modelling on the impact of nuclear energy on power prices. I look forward to the opposition releasing information as to where the nuclear power plants will go. Will it be in Yeppoon or in Yeppen? Where will it be, Mr Speaker! That's what we want to know. The LNP says 'local nuclear power plant'. The SPEAKER: The member for Fairfax was warned numerous times. He will now leave the chamber under 94(a). The member for Fairfax then left the chamber.