Mr TAYLOR (Hume—Minister for Energy and Emissions Reduction) (15:05): Of course I recall seeing and meeting Ms Wolf at New College in Oxford during my time there. She began her studies there in the mid-eighties and she finished at Oxford only a couple of years ago. Now, my speech to the parliament six years ago did not say she was involved in the war on Christmas. But I want to say this: her accusation of anti-Semitism is wrong and deeply offensive to me and my family. Mr Speaker, my grandmother was Jewish, and my belief in Judaeo-Christian values is deeply held. I call on Ms Wolf to apologise for these unsubstantiated and outrageous accusations. Opposition members interjecting— The SPEAKER: Members on my left! Mr TAYLOR: The fact that the Labor Party has attached itself to anti-Semitic accusations shows you just how low they're prepared to go. The SPEAKER: The Leader of the Opposition, on a point of order? Mr Albanese: Yes. From where it came is beyond me, Mr Speaker, but this minister just accused us of being anti-Semitic. He's got to withdraw it. Opposition members interjecting— The SPEAKER: Members on my left! The Leader of the House has the call. Mr Porter: No point of order has been nominated. What standing order is he seeking to raise? The SPEAKER: He wasn't raising a point of order. That last statement does need to be withdrawn. I call the minister. Mr TAYLOR: I withdraw.