Mr BUTLER (Port Adelaide) (14:36): My question is to the Prime Minister. Just over three months ago, the Prime Minister described the clean energy target this way: Well it would certainly work, there is no question it would work … And: It has a number of virtues, very strong virtues. And, again: … it has a lot of merit and as I say we will look at it very favourably … Prime Minister, will there be a clean energy target, yes or no? Honourable members interjecting— The SPEAKER: The members on my left! And right! The Minister for Social Services! The Treasurer! I remind the member for Hunter that he has already been warned. The Prime Minister has the call.