Mr WHITELEY (Braddon) (16:11): I notice those opposite are all leaving, which is so disappointing! I noticed they all came in for Tanya and the 'plebettes', but they are all going now. The DEPUTY SPEAKER: Order! You will refer to members by their seat. Mr WHITELEY: Mr Deputy Speaker, I refer to the one-and a-half-minute mark of the deputy opposition leader's speech when she referred to Christopher Pyne. If she withdraws, I will be happy to. Ms Plibersek: I am happy to withdraw, Mr Deputy Speaker. He is obviously not Christopher Pyne. The DEPUTY SPEAKER: Member for Braddon, this is not conditional: you will also refer to members by their title in this place. Mr WHITELEY: I am happy to withdraw. This is an interesting matter of public importance. Opposition members interjecting— Mr WHITELEY: You should listen over there. You might learn something. There is a bullfrog noise coming from the third row over there. I am not sure what it is. This matter of public importance has been brought to this House by a Leader of the Opposition whose life is littered with disloyalty to previous Prime Ministers who are still pulling knives out of their back, colleagues who do not speak to him anymore because of those very actions and many in the unions who have come to not trust this man. He is the sort of guy who turns up to the MCG on a Saturday afternoon to watch his favourite footy team and, if at half-time it is not going so well, he swaps sides. The man has no loyalty in him whatsoever. If you look up the definition of 'chaotic' in the dictionary, the Australian Labor Party quickly pops up. What gall you have! The DEPUTY SPEAKER: I hope you are not referring to me, Member for Braddon, when you refer to 'you'. Mr WHITELEY: No, Mr Deputy Speaker—certainly not. What gall from those down the front! They have done everything they can to constrain a newly elected government from implementing a strategy that was given approval by the Australian people. They stood by the carbon tax to the bitter end. What gall from a political party that left an economic trail of destruction. When she was health minister, the Deputy Leader of the Opposition presided over a health system that was in absolute chaos. If you are wondering where the Minister for Health is, he is out there cleaning up your mess. He is out there trying to find the superclinics that have never appeared. He is out there trying to fix the absolute mess you left. All you did was put backroom public servants into a job and collect the union fees. You are a failed health minister. Mr Stephen Jones: I rise on a point of order. I rise to defend your honour, Mr Deputy Speaker. The things the member said about you are not fair. The DEPUTY SPEAKER ( Hon. BC Scott ): I thank the member for Throsby for his assistance. The member for Braddon will refer his comments through the chair. The use of the word 'you' is a reflection on the chair. Mr WHITELEY: Mr Deputy Speaker, through you, this lot over here have got no shame. They have ruined this country. You went off to try and fix a problem and put pink batts into roofs, and you killed people—that is the bottom line. That is what happened. And that is what the royal commission has shown. The DEPUTY SPEAKER: Member for Ballarat, I will take your point of order. I know what it is. Ms King: Mr Deputy Speaker, I ask the member to withdraw that comment. It is utterly offensive and he should know better. It is unparliamentary. The DEPUTY SPEAKER: I ask the member for Braddon to withdraw that comment, which was a reflection on the opposition members that they killed people. Mr WHITELEY: Mr Deputy Speaker, I withdraw. But the policies of this government— Opposition members: Withdraw! Mr WHITELEY: I did. Are you deaf? I know you are dumb, but are you deaf? The DEPUTY SPEAKER: Order! The member for Braddon will resume his seat. An opposition member: He should be thrown out, Deputy Speaker. He is out of control. The DEPUTY SPEAKER: Order! The Leader of Opposition Business on the point of order. Mr Burke: Mr Deputy Speaker, I would simply ask that the member adhere to the previous rulings that you have given and address the parliament in an appropriate way. The DEPUTY SPEAKER: The member for Braddon did withdraw. The member for Braddon has the call, and I will remind him of the motion before the chamber. Mr WHITELEY: I am very much reminded of the motion, which talks about chaos. It talks about 'chaotic'. I will talk about chaotic. What about the live trade decision that left cattle farmers in the north of Queensland in absolute bankruptcy? (Time expired) The DEPUTY SPEAKER ( Hon. BC Scott ): Order! The discussion is now concluded.