Mr SHORTEN (Maribyrnong—Leader of the Opposition) (14:05): My question is to the Prime Minister. A single-income family with two children earning $65,000 a year will be $6,000 a year worse off because of the Prime Minister's broken promises on the GP tax, the petrol tax, family payments and cost of living. Isn't it true that no matter what the Prime Minister says this week, Australians will still be $6,000 worse off because of his budget?