Senator WATT (Queensland—Minister for the Environment and Water) (14:57): Thanks to Senator Walker, who has already demonstrated what a strong force for young Australians she has been as senator for South Australia. After a decade of neglect from the Liberals, Australia had the second-worst skills shortage in all advanced economies. Since coming to office, the Albanese Labor government hasn't wasted a day in helping Australians to get the skills they want for the jobs we need to fill. That's why we introduced the Key Apprenticeship Program, which pays $10,000 in incentives to new apprentices in the housing and clean energy sectors. Nearly 30,000 Australians have signed up for apprenticeships under the program, and these are the chippies, plumbers, brickies and sparkies we need to build Australian homes and deliver the clean-energy transition. What we learned over the weekend is that this key program, which is helping provide the tradies needed to build the homes our country needs, is one the coalition want to cut. In her first contribution as the new shadow minister for skills and training, Senator Nampijinpa Price told Josh Martin from Channel 7 that the opposition would scrap this vital scheme. They want to scrap the program that is training Australians to become tradies. It seems— The PRESIDENT: Senator Nampijinpa Price? Senator Nampijinpa Price: Point of order. The minister is misleading the Senate. It is simply untrue. He's lying once more. Honourable senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senator, that isn't a point of order. Senator Wong? Senator Wong: Could the Shadow Minister withdraw what she just said at the conclusion of her point of order? You can't say that. The PRESIDENT: Sorry. Because of all the interjections, I did not hear, but I will ask the senator. Senator Nampijinpa Price— Opposition senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senators, stop arguing back and forth across the chamber. Thank you. You have asked for a withdrawal, and I will ask the senator. Senator Nampijinpa Price, there was a lot of noise on my right, and I didn't hear, but I'm sure that, if there were something that you said that was unparliamentary, you would withdraw. The Clerk has advised me that you should withdraw. Senator Nampijinpa Price: I withdraw. The PRESIDENT: Thank you. Senator WATT: It does seem that Senator Nampijinpa Price is another of the coalition members who haven't yet read the Liberal Party's secret review, which I tabled here on Tuesday. Recommendation 6 of the secret review states: The Federal Parliamentary Party, which has the privilege of determining the Party's federal policies, must in future and especially in opposition … consult with the Party Organisation on the formulation of policy, and … do so in a timely manner. It is clear that there was a significant breakdown in the required consultation process, to the detriment of the 2025 campaign. The Parliamentary leader needs to account for the development of sound policy to the Party. So the question is: did the opposition leader know about this new coalition policy to scrap this key program, or was this more freelancing from Senator Nampijinpa Price, just like her support for making Australia great again in the election campaign that went so well? The PRESIDENT: Senator Walker, first supplementary?