Senator CANAVAN (Queensland) (15:02): Thank you, Madam Acting President. Well, Minister— The PRESIDENT: Senator, I'm not the 'acting president'. Senator CANAVAN: Sorry, Madam President. Minister, we didn't have a ridiculous 82 per cent renewable energy target, but you have. We didn't have that. Frank Future is the owner of Imagine Cruises at Port Stephens in New South Wales. He left Port Stephens at 3 am to make sure he could get here today. He is concerned that his whale watching and dolphin cruise business will be decimated by the proposed offshore wind farm, which will harm wildlife and destroy his important tourism economy. Why is this government so intent on destroying our environment in pursuit of its ridiculous 82 per cent renewable energy target? An incident having occurred in the gallery— The PRESIDENT: Before I call the minister, I remind those in the gallery that, if you interject again, you will be removed. I also remind those in the chamber that— Honourable senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Order! Senator Canavan interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Order! Senator Canavan, you've asked a serious question. I presume you want an answer. I also ask senators not to interject because Senator Canavan has the right to ask his question in silence.