Senator BIRMINGHAM (South Australia—Minister for Finance, Leader of the Government in the Senate and Vice-President of the Executive Council) (15:12): I would not usually rise to speak on a motion to take note, particularly a motion to take note of an answer that I have given. However, we have just seen quite an extraordinary display by Senator Patrick. Senator Patrick interjecting— The DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Order, Senator Patrick. Honourable senators interjecting— The DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Senators! I will call you to order, please. The minister has the right to be heard in silence. Senator BIRMINGHAM: We have just seen the most extraordinary display by Senator Patrick, impugning motives against senior officials in the Australian Public Service, having already on a previous occasion singled out in quite an extraordinary way an individual senior public servant. Senator Patrick interjecting— The DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Order! Senator BIRMINGHAM: It is entirely appropriate for the Secretary of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet to seek to defend public servants working across the Australian Public Service from being brought into improper political debate. Senator Patrick interjecting— The DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Senator Patrick, we heard you in silence. I would ask you to show the same respect back to the minister. Senator BIRMINGHAM: Those of us who serve in public office are fair game in this place for the political debates that occur. We bring many public servants into the limelight as part of Senate estimates processes and other processes of government to provide the opportunity for questioning and the opportunity for information-gathering across our democratic processes. But we ought to respect that those public servants are not elected officials and they are not public officials. They are individuals who rightly have accountability mechanisms and processes in place for the way in which they conduct their duties. Of course, as ministers, we are responsible for the work of our departments and for addressing those matters. I acknowledge that, overwhelmingly, members of this place and members of the other place have respected the work of the Australian Public Service and have not sought to create this type of politicised attack on individuals within it. I acknowledge that the President will consider the matters before him and, if necessary, the privileges committee will consider those matters. But, certainly on behalf of the government, I wish to make clear our respect for the work of our Public Service officials and leaders, including those individuals who have been maligned in the comments by Senator Patrick. Question agreed to.