Mr SWAN (Lilley—Deputy Prime Minister and Treasurer) (15:17): I have already addressed all of the issues associated with that question. When we have designed the emissions trading scheme we will announce all the details and then we will have a debate about its impact for business and households, its benefit to the country in the long term and the short term, and the fact that we are going to set this country up so we can prosper into the future with lower carbon growth absolutely critical to the future of this country although not understood by any of those opposite apparently. Mr Baldwin: Mr Speaker, on a point of order: I point specifically to the issue of relevance. I asked specifically what compensation will the government be providing to businesses like Rex. The SPEAKER: Order! the Treasurer is responding to the question. Mr SWAN: I have said the government is working its way through all these issues to design the scheme. We do that in good faith. We do it in the national interest. What this is all about from those opposite today is to cover over the very deep divisions that we have seen on their side of politics—deep divisions over tobacco, deep divisions over tax, deep divisions over climate change—which have been all too apparent out there in the papers day after day. That is what we have—a smokescreen to cover up for the fact there is no alternative economic policy and no vision for the future of the country whatsoever.