Senator CORMANN (Western Australia—Minister for Finance and the Public Service, Vice-President of the Executive Council and Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:47): Senator Ciccone, I welcome you to this chamber and I wish you a very successful career for many years to come—hopefully for quite a bit longer on the opposition benches. What I would advise you very genuinely is, when you're handed questions by your tactics committee, perhaps try and listen to the answer to the primary question before you just read out the first supplementary that you are handed, because the premise of the question is entirely wrong. If you had listened to my answer to the primary question, you would know that the premise of the question is entirely wrong, because Australians at the lower income end are getting higher tax cuts on the percentage that— Senator Wong: Oh, percentages— Senator CORMANN: 'Oh percentages', says Senator Wong; yes, indeed. Let me repeat it: somebody on $30,000 a year gets a 10.6 per cent tax cut under our government, whereas somebody on $200,000 a year gets a 0.2 per cent tax cut. (Time expired) Honourable senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Order on my left, now on my right! Senator O'Neill interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senator O'Neill, I've just called order; your colleague is waiting to get on his feet. Senator Ciccone on a final supplementary question.