Senator CASH (Western Australia—Minister for Jobs and Innovation) (14:08): The answer is yes. Opposition senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Order on my left! Senator Cash: I can hear him from the other side—Senator Carr! Senator Kim Carr interjecting— Senator Cameron interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senators Carr and Cameron. Senator CASH: Senator Carr was responsible for Labor's antibusiness and antimanufacturing policies which saw manufacturers in Australia leave this country. It is a fact that, under the policies which Senator Carr presided over, one in eight manufacturing jobs in Australia disappeared. (Time expired)