Senator ROBERTS (Queensland) (14:30): As a servant to the people of Queensland and Australia, my question is to the Minister representing the Minister for the Environment and Energy, Senator Birmingham. Are you aware, Senator, that in Senate estimates in May your colleague Senator Macdonald asked the Chief Scientist, 'What would be the impact of ceasing all'—not five per cent, not 28 per cent, not 50 per cent, not 95 per cent—'Australian production of carbon dioxide?' and the Chief Scientist answered, 'Virtually nothing'?
In this debate Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Zimmerman, Trent, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Macklin, Jenny, MP Porter, Christian, MP Falinski, Jason, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Plibersek, Tanya, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Sharkie, Rebekha, MP Pyne, Christopher, MP Kelly, Craig, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Christensen, George, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Butler, Mark, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Irons, Steve, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Butler, Mark, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Wallace, Andrew, MP Pyne, Christopher, MP Butler, Mark, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Ramsey, Rowan, MP Hunt, Greg, MP Butler, Mark, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Landry, Michelle, MP Ciobo, Steven, MP Albanese, Anthony, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP O'Dowd, Ken, MP McCormack, Michael, MP McBride, Emma, MP Fletcher, Paul, MP Wood, Jason, MP Dutton, Peter, MP Collins, Sen Jacinta Brandis, Sen George Collins, Sen Jacinta Brandis, Sen George Collins, Sen Jacinta Brandis, Sen George Hume, Sen Jane Cash, Sen Michaelia Hume, Sen Jane Cash, Sen Michaelia Hume, Sen Jane Cash, Sen Michaelia Chisholm, Sen Anthony Cormann, Sen Mathias Chisholm, Sen Anthony Cormann, Sen Mathias Chisholm, Sen Anthony Cormann, Sen Mathias Di Natale, Sen Richard Brandis, Sen George Di Natale, Sen Richard Brandis, Sen George Di Natale, Sen Richard Brandis, Sen George Wong, Sen Penny Cash, Sen Michaelia Wong, Sen Penny Cash, Sen Michaelia Wong, Sen Penny Cash, Sen Michaelia Birmingham, Sen Simon Roberts, Sen Malcolm Birmingham, Sen Simon Roberts, Sen Malcolm Birmingham, Sen Simon McKenzie, Sen Bridget Nash, Sen Fiona McKenzie, Sen Bridget Nash, Sen Fiona McKenzie, Sen Bridget Nash, Sen Fiona Kakoschke-Moore, Sen Skye Payne, Sen Marise Kakoschke-Moore, Sen Skye Payne, Sen Marise Kakoschke-Moore, Sen Skye Payne, Sen Marise McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Payne, Sen Marise McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Payne, Sen Marise McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Payne, Sen Marise Reynolds, Sen Linda Cash, Sen Michaelia Reynolds, Sen Linda Cash, Sen Michaelia Reynolds, Sen Linda Cash, Sen Michaelia Polley, Sen Helen Brandis, Sen George Polley, Sen Helen Brandis, Sen George Polley, Sen Helen Brandis, Sen George