Senator BRANDIS (Queensland—Attorney-General, Vice-President of the Executive Council and Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:45): Senator Cameron, I think you are referring to the discussion we had yesterday in the government party room about the Finkel report, are you not? I know that Mr Craig Kelly has expressed some views. He has expressed them within the forums of the coalition and he has expressed them publicly as well. He is a voice in this debate, and we are glad to hear his views. I know you old socialists find this very hard to understand, but we in the Liberal Party and in the National Party— Opposition senators interjecting— Senator BRANDIS: You 'Corbynites'! We in the Liberal Party actually think that any discussion is improved by hearing a variety of opinions. That is why Mr Kelly's views, like the views of each and every one of my coalition colleagues in this discussion, are a welcome contribution. As a result of that discussion— Senator Cameron: Mr President, I rise on a point of order on relevance. There were two questions asked: one was whether the government was fully aware of the assumptions; the second was were the baseline findings made available to the party room. The minister has not gone near any of those questions. The PRESIDENT: Thank you, Senator Cameron. I will remind the minister of the questions. Senator BRANDIS: So, Senator Cameron, Mr Kelly's views are very welcome in this debate. Now, you raised two particular matters. What I can tell you, Senator Cameron, is that the Finkel report was published when the government received it. So it is a public document. The Finkel report contains a great deal of analysis and charts of tables and various other expositions of that analysis, which the minister, Mr Frydenberg, took our party room through yesterday morning, and that included the issue of the baseline. Of course the baseline is an important issue; we are aware of that. Senator Cameron, there was discussion about all of these issues. There was a briefing by Mr Frydenberg about all of these issues and there were contributions about a variety of issues, including that one, because, as I said to your acting leader, that is the way we do policy. We have a free and open discussion. (Time expired) The PRESIDENT: Senator Cameron, a supplementary question.