Senator SINODINOS (New South Wales—Minister for Industry, Innovation and Science) (14:44): In the last 12 months, manufacturing employment has gone up. Employment across the economy is going up. We have just had the NAB survey come out today and talk about how these are the best conditions since before the GFC in terms of business confidence and the outlook for investment. We are transitioning the economy to more non-mining investment to take account of the fall-off in mining investment, so I do not accept the premise that jobs are going backwards under this government. They are going up. By the way, we do not just rely on government to create jobs. We create an environment for the private sector to create jobs.
In this debate Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Wicks, Lucy, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Butler, Mark, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Pasin, Tony, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Swanson, Meryl, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Katter, Bob, MP Fletcher, Paul, MP O'Dowd, Ken, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Christensen, George, MP Dutton, Peter, MP Burke, Tony, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Andrews, Kevin, MP Pyne, Christopher, MP Macklin, Jenny, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Wood, Jason, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Porter, Christian, MP Vasta, Ross, MP Ciobo, Steven, MP Bowen, Chris, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Banks, Julia, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Plibersek, Tanya, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Landry, Michelle, MP Tehan, Dan, MP Fitzgibbon, Joel, MP Ketter, Sen Christopher Brandis, Sen George Ketter, Sen Christopher Brandis, Sen George Ketter, Sen Christopher Brandis, Sen George Williams, Sen John Scullion, Sen Nigel Williams, Sen John Scullion, Sen Nigel Williams, Sen John Scullion, Sen Nigel Sterle, Sen Glenn Cormann, Sen Mathias Sterle, Sen Glenn Cormann, Sen Mathias Sterle, Sen Glenn Cormann, Sen Mathias Siewert, Sen Rachel Ryan, Sen Scott Siewert, Sen Rachel Ryan, Sen Scott Siewert, Sen Rachel Ryan, Sen Scott Fawcett, Sen David Birmingham, Sen Simon Fawcett, Sen David Birmingham, Sen Simon Fawcett, Sen David Birmingham, Sen Simon Collins, Sen Jacinta Brandis, Sen George Collins, Sen Jacinta Brandis, Sen George Collins, Sen Jacinta Brandis, Sen George Reynolds, Sen Linda Payne, Sen Marise Reynolds, Sen Linda Payne, Sen Marise Reynolds, Sen Linda Payne, Sen Marise Hinch, Sen Derryn Brandis, Sen George Hinch, Sen Derryn Brandis, Sen George Hinch, Sen Derryn Brandis, Sen George Carr, Sen Kim Sinodinos, Sen Arthur Carr, Sen Kim Sinodinos, Sen Arthur Carr, Sen Kim O'Sullivan, Sen Barry Canavan, Sen Matthew O'Sullivan, Sen Barry Canavan, Sen Matthew O'Sullivan, Sen Barry Canavan, Sen Matthew Watt, Sen Murray Payne, Sen Marise Watt, Sen Murray Payne, Sen Marise Watt, Sen Murray Payne, Sen Marise Back, Sen Chris Fierravanti-Wells, Sen Concetta Back, Sen Chris Fierravanti-Wells, Sen Concetta Back, Sen Chris Fierravanti-Wells, Sen Concetta Gallagher, Sen Katy Brandis, Sen George Gallagher, Sen Katy Brandis, Sen George Gallagher, Sen Katy Brandis, Sen George