Senator CASH (Western Australia—Minister Assisting the Prime Minister for the Public Service, Minister for Employment and Minister for Women) (14:52): Senators will be aware that the government has proposed vital reforms to protect hard-working union members by cleaning up the bad behaviour of trade union officials and providing stronger laws for both trade union and employer organisations. Why have we done this? Because hard-working union members should not have their money misappropriated to pay for, for example, extravagant holidays, sex toys, tattoos, concert tickets, imported cars and dating services; they should not have their money misappropriated by officials who think that the hard-working members' money is their own to fund their lifestyles. We have repeatedly brought legislation before this Senate to ensure greater transparency and more accountability of both union and employer organisations. But you have heard the shrieks from those on the other side— (Time expired) The PRESIDENT: Point of order, Senator Macdonald? Senator Ian Macdonald: I am sorry to interrupt the question and I did not want to interrupt the minister, but I heard Senator Bilyk say, in response to Senator Cash's first answer, that the 'women should toughen up' and I would ask that she be asked to withdraw that. The PRESIDENT: There is no point of order. Senator Wong: If I may make it clear: as I understood it, Mr President, Senator Bilyk was actually suggesting Senator Paterson toughen up. The PRESIDENT: In any event, there is no point of order. Senator Paterson, final supplementary question.