Senator BRANDIS (Queensland—Attorney-General, Vice-President of the Executive Council and Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:18): Senator, I can tell you that the government is committed to renewable energy. We are committed to renewable energy, we are committed to emissions reduction and we are committed to policies that actually deliver real outcomes. That is why you referred to the Prime Minister's speech in Paris. That is why, in his speech in Paris, the Prime Minister committed Australia to the second-most ambitious emissions reduction target per capita of any G20 nation: an emissions reduction target of 2005 levels by 2030 of 52 per cent per capita. That is the second-most ambitious of any of the G20 nations. That is a responsible climate policy. It is a responsible climate policy—unlike yours, Senator Di Natale—which proposes 90 per cent renewable energy without costing the policy, without indicating who would pay for the policy— The PRESIDENT: Pause the clock! A point of order, Senator Di Natale? Senator Di Natale: Yes, Mr President. I acknowledge that there was a long preamble, and I have given the minister an opportunity to give a speech. However, my question was straightforward: has the Prime Minister done a deal with the National Party to ensure that fossil fuel subsidies continue? The PRESIDENT: Thank you, Senator Di Natale. I will remind the minister of the question. Senator BRANDIS: Senator Di Natale, when you say 'done a deal with the National Party': we are a coalition government, and all decisions that the government makes in all areas of policy, including in relation to climate policy, are the result of discussions among Liberal and National Party cabinet ministers. So every aspect of this government's climate policy, one of the most ambitious emissions reductions in the world on a per capita basis, is the result of a decision jointly made by Liberal Party ministers and National Party ministers through an orthodox cabinet process. We are very proud of that cooperation, we are very proud of that partnership and we are very proud of the sensible outcomes that those deliberations produce.